Chapter 1

Romeo & Juliet vs. Don Giovanni

Here’s a table comparing Romeo and Juliet by Shakespeare and Don Giovanni by Mozart:

Aspect	Romeo and Juliet (Shakespeare)	Don Giovanni (Mozart)
Genre	Tragedy	Dramma giocoso (mix of serious and comic opera)
Main Theme	Forbidden love, fate, and tragedy	Seduction, punishment, and the supernatural
Protagonists	Romeo and Juliet	Don Giovanni
Plot Summary	Two young lovers from feuding families fall in love and tragically die.	Don Giovanni, a libertine, seduces women and ultimately faces retribution from the supernatural.
Moral Lesson	Love can transcend hate, but impulsivity and societal constraints can lead to tragedy.	Excess, lust, and immorality will eventually lead to downfall and punishment, no matter how invincible one may seem.
Time Period	Late 16th century	Premiered in 1787, set in Seville, Spain
Setting	Verona, Italy	Seville, Spain
Character Arcs	Juliet matures from naive girl to a determined woman; Romeo transforms from melancholic to passionate.	Don Giovanni remains unrepentant, static in his libertine ways, while characters like Donna Anna and Don Ottavio seek justice and revenge.
Notable Musical/Poetic Structure	Written in iambic pentameter, with sonnets and soliloquies that add emotional depth to characters.	A blend of arias, recitatives, and ensembles. Notable use of leitmotifs (e.g., the Commendatore’s theme) to represent fate and the supernatural.
Ending	Both protagonists die, leaving behind a tragic legacy of love lost to societal pressures.	Don Giovanni is dramatically dragged to hell by the statue of the Commendatore, marking his supernatural punishment.
Notable Symbolism	The poison and the dagger, symbolizing both love’s intensity and its fatal consequences.	The statue of the Commendatore, embodying divine justice and inevitable retribution.
Central Conflict	Love vs. familial/societal expectations, resulting in tragedy.	Recklessness and seduction vs. morality, leading to supernatural punishment.
Use of Supernatural	Limited, though there are dreamlike or fate-driven interpretations.	Prominent, with the Commendatore’s ghost embodying justice from beyond the grave.
Treatment of Social Classes	The feud between the Montagues and Capulets is a tragedy that consumes both nobility and commoners.	Don Giovanni, an aristocrat, abuses his privilege, manipulating both peasants and nobles alike, most notably with characters like Zerlina and Masetto.
Representation of Healing	Romeo’s desperate reliance on the apothecary’s poison leads to death, not healing—a symbol of despair.	Zerlina offers Masetto “something better than an apothecary” after Don Giovanni’s men beat him, highlighting deception and manipulation through promises of comfort, though the underlying betrayal remains.

Detailed Insights:

1. Healing vs. Deception: In Romeo and Juliet, the apothecary is associated with death and despair. Romeo’s purchase of poison from the apothecary is a desperate act, one that seals his tragic fate. The apothecary himself, impoverished and morally conflicted, provides the poison out of necessity rather than malicious intent, symbolizing the darker consequences of societal pressures and personal despair.

   In Don Giovanni, the apothecary metaphor is more light-hearted but equally ironic. When Zerlina promises Masetto “something better than an apothecary” after he’s beaten by Don Giovanni’s men, she’s offering emotional comfort and perhaps even romantic affection as a means of soothing his physical and emotional wounds. However, this line drips with irony, as Zerlina is herself unfaithful, caught in Don Giovanni’s manipulative web. Her promise may sound tender, but it reflects the opera’s themes of deception and the fragile façade of relationships.

2. Symbolism of the Apothecary: While the apothecary in Romeo and Juliet is a direct agent of death, in Don Giovanni the mention of an apothecary symbolizes a more metaphorical healing—emotional and relational, rather than physical. The juxtaposition in Don Giovanni is comedic but carries undertones of the moral instability that defines Don Giovanni’s world. Even promises of healing and affection are undermined by infidelity and deceit.

3. Supernatural Punishment: The supernatural element in Don Giovanni takes center stage, with the Commendatore’s statue actively enacting divine justice. The ghostly figure stands in stark contrast to the more human tragedies in Romeo and Juliet. While fate and miscommunication drive the lovers to their doom, it is human error rather than divine intervention that results in their deaths. Don Giovanni’s supernatural retribution, on the other hand, is an external force bringing punishment beyond human control, making his downfall more theatrical but also less rooted in personal choice.

---

This comparison underscores the stark contrast in tone and thematic resolution between Romeo and Juliet and Don Giovanni. While Shakespeare explores the consequences of human decisions and societal pressures in a grounded, tragic manner, Mozart’s opera embraces the comic and supernatural to expose the empty promises of pleasure and the inevitable consequences of unchecked immorality. The treatment of the apothecary in both works highlights this difference—one as a serious, fatalistic figure and the other as a metaphor for hollow comfort.