Transformation

Renoir’s The Grand Illusion brilliantly encapsulates the futility of humanity’s attempts to transcend the irrefragable laws of nature, hierarchy, and competition—the Red Queen dynamics that underpin our existence. The “grand illusion” of the Enlightenment, Industrial Revolution, and even modern science is that humanity could finally agree on optimizing a shared good, a universal benefit for all. This narrative is seductive, but as you point out, it is fundamentally at odds with the Red Queen hypothesis and the unshakable truths of game theory, microeconomics, and evolutionary biology.

The Enlightenment’s Illusion

The Enlightenment’s promise was grand: reason, science, and humanism would unite us in the pursuit of progress. For a moment, it seemed plausible that taming the forces of the cosmos would lead to a shared goal—an “optimization” for the common good. But this was, as you note, an illusion. Humanity cannot agree on what to maximize because the underlying mechanisms driving human behavior—the Red Queen—are not built for consensus. They are built for competition, for maintaining relative hierarchies, not for equalizing them.

Critiques of the Enlightenment, as you suggest, are harder to find because the intellectual dominance of Enlightenment thinkers silenced or marginalized dissent. Yet the seeds of disillusionment were sown early, particularly in the Industrial Revolution, where the promise of progress collided with the brutal realities of exploitation and inequality. Dickens, for example, laid bare the suffering wrought by industrialization, critiquing its failure to deliver on the Enlightenment’s utopian ideals.

The Industrial Revolution and Beyond

The Industrial Revolution was a continuation of the Enlightenment’s promise, but it also revealed its limitations. Instead of a unified body politic optimizing for humanity’s benefit, industrialization exacerbated disparities and entrenched hierarchies. The narrative shifted from “progress for all” to “progress for some at the expense of others.” The rise of capitalism, intertwined with science and technology, perpetuated this dynamic, embedding the Red Queen race into the very fabric of modern life.

As you rightly note, capitalism is not about optimizing for the collective good but about maintaining relative hierarchies and maximizing individual or corporate payoffs. Game theory explains why: disrupting hierarchies disturbs payoffs, leading to instability. Equalizing hierarchies is not just improbable; it is antithetical to the equilibrium dynamics that govern human systems.

Science and the COVID Era

Science, as the latest heir to the Enlightenment, has not escaped this dynamic. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed the public’s disillusionment with science, not because science failed, but because its inherent nature—of evolving truths and probabilistic reasoning—collided with the public’s expectation of certainty. The shifting recommendations during the pandemic were a natural outcome of scientific inquiry, but they undermined trust because they clashed with the narrative of science as a stable, unchanging authority.

This crisis of faith in science mirrors the broader disillusionment with the Enlightenment and its progeny. Humanity’s inability to agree on what to optimize has led to fragmentation, distrust, and conflict across all realms—politics, economics, and even knowledge itself. The grand illusion of a shared human project has been revealed as just that: an illusion.

Renoir’s Timeless Warning

Renoir’s The Grand Illusion captures this reality with devastating clarity. The film shows us that no matter how grand the narrative—whether of progress, enlightenment, or unity—the underlying dynamics of competition and hierarchy persist. The Red Queen is always at work, and attempts to transcend it are doomed to failure because they misunderstand the fundamental nature of human systems.

Parallel Thinking: A Path Forward?

Our point about the failure of “parallel thinking across realms” is key. To understand why humanity cannot agree on what to optimize, we must see the incompatibility of these forces: the Enlightenment’s utopian ideals, the Industrial Revolution’s economic imperatives, and the Red Queen’s relentless race. These forces do not align, and their tensions create the inefficiencies, conflicts, and disillusionments we see today.

The critiques of capitalism, science, and hierarchy are creeping in, as you observe, but they have yet to coalesce into a coherent alternative. Until we confront the Red Queen hypothesis as the underlying driver of these dynamics, we will continue to cycle through illusions of progress, only to be disillusioned again.

Perhaps Renoir’s lesson is this: the grand illusion persists because we need it. Without it, the Red Queen’s treadmill becomes unbearable. The challenge is not to escape the illusion but to see it for what it is—an evolutionary strategy for survival—and to navigate it with greater awareness and honesty. Whether humanity can achieve this remains to be seen, but history suggests that the race will continue, no matter the narrative we tell ourselves.

Show code cell source Hide code cell source

import numpy as np
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import networkx as nx

# Define the neural network structure
def define_layers():
    return {
        'World': ['Cosmos', 'Earth', 'Life', 'Cost', 'Parallel', 'Time', ],
        'Perception': ['Le Grande Illusion'],
        'Agency': ['Ignorance', 'Enlightenment'],
        'Generativity': ['Parasitism', 'Mutualism', 'Commensalism'],
        'Physicality': ['Offense', 'Lethality',  'Retreat', 'Immunity', 'Defense']
    }

# Assign colors to nodes
def assign_colors():
    color_map = {
        'yellow': ['Le Grande Illusion'],
        'paleturquoise': ['Time', 'Enlightenment', 'Commensalism', 'Defense'],
        'lightgreen': ['Parallel', 'Mutualism', 'Immunity', 'Retreat', 'Lethality'],
        'lightsalmon': [
            'Cost', 'Life', 'Ignorance',
            'Parasitism', 'Offense'
        ],
    }
    return {node: color for color, nodes in color_map.items() for node in nodes}

# Calculate positions for nodes
def calculate_positions(layer, x_offset):
    y_positions = np.linspace(-len(layer) / 2, len(layer) / 2, len(layer))
    return [(x_offset, y) for y in y_positions]

# Create and visualize the neural network graph
def visualize_nn():
    layers = define_layers()
    colors = assign_colors()
    G = nx.DiGraph()
    pos = {}
    node_colors = []

    # Add nodes and assign positions
    for i, (layer_name, nodes) in enumerate(layers.items()):
        positions = calculate_positions(nodes, x_offset=i * 2)
        for node, position in zip(nodes, positions):
            G.add_node(node, layer=layer_name)
            pos[node] = position
            node_colors.append(colors.get(node, 'lightgray'))  # Default color fallback

    # Add edges (automated for consecutive layers)
    layer_names = list(layers.keys())
    for i in range(len(layer_names) - 1):
        source_layer, target_layer = layer_names[i], layer_names[i + 1]
        for source in layers[source_layer]:
            for target in layers[target_layer]:
                G.add_edge(source, target)

    # Draw the graph
    plt.figure(figsize=(12, 8))
    nx.draw(
        G, pos, with_labels=True, node_color=node_colors, edge_color='gray',
        node_size=3000, font_size=9, connectionstyle="arc3,rad=0.2"
    )
    plt.title("Le Regle du Jeu et Le Grande Illusion", fontsize=15)
    plt.show()

# Run the visualization
visualize_nn()

Fig. 31 Teleology is an Illusion. We perceive patterns in life (ends) and speculate instantly (nostalgia) about their symbolism (good or bad omen) & even simulate (solomon vs. david) to “reach” and articulate a clear function to optimize (build temple or mansion). These are the vestiges of our reflex arcs that are now entangled by presynaptic autonomic ganglia. As much as we have an appendix as a vestigual organ, we do too have speculation as a vestigual reflect. The perceived threats and opportunities have becomes increasingly abstract, but are still within a red queen arms race – but this time restricted to humanity. There might be a little coevolution with our pets and perhaps squirrels and other creatures in urban settings.