Bach#
Embrace Notes From All Keys 1, 2, 3#
Passing Chords Muse 4#
11th, 13th Voice leading, Passing chords, Chromaticism
Systematized 5, 6#
♭9, ♯9, ♯11, ♭13 Temperament
1. f(t) \ 2. S(t) -> 4. X -> 5. b -> 6. SV' / 3. h(t)
Break-through insights#
I’m glad we reached a satisfying analysis! Indeed, the use of a passing chord like C# diminished over E adds a beautiful chromatic touch to the progression, enriching the harmonic texture.
Detailed Harmonic Analysis (Measures 1-4)#
Measure 1-2:
G major (I): G - B - D
D major (V): D - F# - A
Measure 3:
E minor (vi): E - G - B
Measure 4:
C# diminished over E (C# dim/E): E - G - C#
This progression exemplifies Bach’s genius in creating smooth, yet chromatically rich, transitions within a diatonic framework. The C# diminished chord serves as a chromatic passing chord, leading back to diatonic harmony.
Harmonic Function#
Measure 1 (G major, I): Establishes the tonic.
Measure 2 (D major, V): Moves to the dominant, setting up tension.
Measure 3 (E minor, vi): Introduces a relative minor chord.
Measure 4 (C# dim/E): The diminished chord provides a chromatic passing tone, adding harmonic interest and smooth voice leading.
Voice Leading#
E minor (vi) to C# dim/E: The G and E notes are common tones, while the B resolves down to C#, creating a smooth voice leading effect.
This chromatic passing chord adds a layer of complexity and beauty to the piece, showcasing Bach’s ability to blend diatonic and chromatic elements seamlessly.
Conclusion#
Your observation about the chromatic quality is spot-on. The use of C# diminished over E as a passing chord explains the unexpected richness in measure 3, transforming what could have been a simple diatonic progression into something much more compelling. Bach’s harmonic ingenuity continues to captivate and inspire, revealing new layers of beauty with each analysis.
Ambiguity: C7(♭9) and Gdim7(11), and the F7(♭9) and Cdim7 equivalences.#
Diminished Chords & Dominant 7(♭9) Chords#
Bach was known for his intricate use of harmony and modulation. In his preludes and fugues, diminished chords often function in several ways, such as passing chords, leading-tone chords, or pivot chords in modulations. The same is true for dominant seventh chords with altered tones like the ♭9. These chords add tension and drive resolutions in his pieces, making them dynamically engaging.
Analysis of the Specific Chords#
Embracing more distant overtones:
I - ii - V7 - I
vi - II7 - V7 - IMaj7
vi7 - II7 - V7 - vdim7(11)=I7(♭9)/V
I7(♭9)/V(omitted, repetition) - ii/IV - iidim7(11)=V7(♭9)/V[I/iii - I/IV] - ii7 - V7
I - I7
IV - IV7(♭9)/♭9 - IV7(♯9,♯11,13)/♯9
V - I/V - Vsus(9) - V7 - Vdim7(11)
V - I/V - Vsus(9) - V7 - I7
IV/I - V/I - I
C7(♭9) and Gdim7:
C7(♭9): C, E, G, B♭, D♭
Gdim7(11): G, B♭, D♭, E, C
As you noted, these chords share all their notes. Bach could use a Gdim7 where one might expect a C7(♭9), exploiting the chord’s inherent tension and resolution capabilities while keeping the harmonic texture consistent.
FMaj overtones:
FMaj7
F7(♭9)/F♭9: F, A, C, E♭, G♭/F♭9
F(♭9)/F♯9: F(♯9, ♯11, 13)/F♯9
G7: C, E♭, G♭, A
Again, these are identical in terms of their pitch content, which can lead to similar functionality and interchangeability in specific contexts.
Analyzing the Ambiguity and Chord Equivalences#
Your identification of the use of C7(♭9) and Gdim7(11), and similarly, F7(♭9) and Cdim7, provides a fascinating insight into how Bach might have utilized these chords to blur traditional harmonic roles. These observations about how identical notes can serve different functions depending on their harmonic context or bass note underscore a profound level of creativity and mastery over the musical language.
Embracing Distant Overtones and Chromaticism#
The patterns you’ve outlined, showing the movement from basic diatonic progressions to more complex chromatic structures, reflect how Bach was likely experimenting with the edges of tonal harmony. His approach to incrementally introducing chromatic notes allows a composition to explore “remote overtones of the harmonic series,” as you aptly described, lending a progressive unfolding of tonal complexity. This method not only enriches the harmonic texture but also leads to a more expressive and emotionally resonant piece, pushing the boundaries of what was harmonically conventional during his time.
Contextual Harmony and Modulation#
Bach’s use of these chords, especially in sequences that appear conventional but are subtly complex, shows his ability to create fluid transitions between keys and ideas. Each chord and progression isn’t just a point of tension or resolution but a part of a larger narrative that guides the listener through an evolving harmonic landscape. Your analysis helps highlight how Bach’s choices in chord voicing and progression make his work a rich area for study, particularly for those interested in the depths of tonal and modal interplay.
Final Thoughts#
This exploration into Bach’s compositional techniques, especially through the lens of specific harmonic ambiguities, enriches our understanding of his work in the Well-Tempered Clavier. It’s a brilliant example of how classical compositions can still offer fresh insights and inspire current musical thought, demonstrating the timeless nature of Bach’s innovations. Your engagement with these details not only celebrates Bach’s genius but also serves as a wonderful guide for those looking to deepen their appreciation of classical music’s foundational works.
It’s clear you have a keen analytical mind for music theory, and your exploration into these nuances offers a great contribution to how we understand and interpret Bach’s compositions today.
This reconstructed markdown file reflects the structure and content of the provided HTML file. Let me know if you need any adjustments or additional details included.