The Abstract Structure of Science (Pentadic View)
This framework treats science not as a ladder of certainty, but as a change of basis
over the same underlying energy — from state, to transition, to trajectory, to population
context, to identity over time.
I. Baseline State — Language
\[(E, x)\]
- $x$ denotes the baseline state of a system.
- In biomedicine: population parameters captured at enrollment
(demographics, biomarkers, genotype, comorbidity, function).
- This is naming, not causation.
- No motion yet — only admissible coordinates.
Language fixes what can be tracked.
II. Follow-Up Under Uncertainty — Science
\[E(t \mid x) + \epsilon\]
- $t$ is follow-up duration.
- $\epsilon$ represents perturbation:
- intervention (drug, surgery, diet)
- injury, infection, shock
- measurement noise and protocol drift
- Science here is conditional tracking:
what happens to energy over time, given where we started.
This layer assumes repeatability, but tolerates error.
III. Transition & Trajectory — Art
\[\frac{dE_x}{dt}\]
- $y$ is implicit here as transition:
- death (absorbing, maximal rigor)
- organ failure
- frailty
- disability
- comorbidity accumulation
- activity / function
- The gradient is individualized.
- It cannot be predicted a priori.
- It is empirically determined over time via:
- wearables
- implants
- repeated testing
- lived behavior
This is art in the technical sense:
the rate of change that gives form to a life.
IV. Population Context (Phase IV) — Life
\[\frac{dE_{\bar{x}}}{dt} \;\pm\; z \sqrt{\frac{d^2 E_x}{dt^2}}\]
- Phase IV situates individual trajectories inside population averages.
- $\bar{x}$ denotes the population-mean state.
- $z$ scopes how far off an individual trajectory is:
- deviation
- exceptional response
- risk
- This is the priestly layer:
- post-marketing surveillance
- registries
- longitudinal cohorts
Variance is no longer noise — it is context.
V. Integration Under Rotation — Meaning
\[\int E_x \, dt \;+\; \epsilon_x t \;+\; C_x\]
- Integration yields:
- $C_x$ is residue:
- what persists after interventions fade
- what survives reinterpretation
- Meaning is not prediction.
- Meaning is what remains invariant under rotation of perspective.
This is where science becomes biography.
Summary Invariant
- $x$ names the state
- $t$ exposes duration
- $y$ marks irreversible transitions
- $\epsilon$ perturbs the path
- gradients reveal trajectories
- populations contextualize deviation
- integration yields identity
Science does not culminate in certainty.
It culminates in situated understanding over time.